The application is no longer the evidence: What should replace it?

Posted on: 11/11/2026

Thought Leadership

Chloe Herrmann explores how the growing use of AI creates more polished applications, making it harder for employers to distinguish between candidates and assess genuine capability. The article highlights practical approaches, including structured interviews, work samples and clear guidance on responsible AI use, to help public sector organisations move beyond written applications, gather meaningful evidence and maintain fair, transparent recruitment.

By Chloe Herrmann, Principle Consultant - Resourcing at West Midlands Employers

If you've spent any time involved in recruitment over the past year, you've probably noticed something changing.

Applications are becoming increasingly polished. Examples are better structured. Supporting statements are more closely aligned to person specifications. In many cases, candidates appear stronger on paper than they might have done only a few years ago.

At first glance, that should be good news.

Yet many recruiters and hiring managers are experiencing something quite different. While applications appear stronger, distinguishing between candidates is becoming increasingly difficult, and confidence in what those applications actually tell us is beginning to shift.

The reason is hardly surprising - AI is now part of everyday life. Tools such as Copilot, Claude and ChatGPT can help candidates structure responses, improve written communication and present their experience more effectively. Increasingly, they are being used in much the same way as spell checkers, grammar tools and search engines once were.

This is where the conversation often becomes unhelpful.

The immediate reaction in some organisations has been to ask whether AI should be banned from the recruitment process altogether. I understand the concern; however, I believe it risks focusing on the wrong issue.

The challenge isn't that candidates are using AI – it’s that many recruitment processes were designed for a world where a written application was a more reliable indicator of capability than it is today.

The sea of sameness

One phrase I've heard repeatedly this year is that applications are beginning to feel the same - not identical or necessarily dishonest, but they are increasingly similar.

As AI helps more candidates improve structure, language and presentation, written applications become less useful as a differentiator. We are seeing more examples that tick the right boxes, use the right terminology and align neatly with person specifications. In some cases, shortlisting risks becoming little more than a search for key phrases and familiar language.

The difficulty is that recruitment was never supposed to be a game of buzzword bingo.

What employers really need is evidence.

Not simply that a candidate says they have stakeholder management skills, but where they demonstrated them. Not that they claim experience of leading change, but what they actually did, what challenges they faced and what impact they achieved. Not that they understand a subject in theory, but that they can apply that knowledge in practice.

As applications become more polished, the quality, specificity and credibility of that evidence becomes increasingly important.

Rethinking the role of the application

For many years, the written application has been one of the most heavily weighted stages of public sector recruitment.

That worked reasonably well when applications provided a relatively strong indication of an individual's ability to interpret a question, structure a response and communicate their experience.

Today, however, we may need to think differently.

The application should increasingly be viewed as a starting point rather than a conclusion.

This doesn't mean abandoning CVs and applications. They remain an important part of the process. But if technology is making it easier for candidates to produce stronger written submissions, employers need to think carefully about how they gather evidence beyond the application itself.

It may also mean reconsidering the types of questions we ask. Rather than asking candidates simply to explain how they meet a broad competency, employers could ask them to describe a specific situation, the decision they made, the action they personally took and the impact it achieved. You could also do this using video technology in your ATS, rather than a written response. The distinction matters: shortlisting should not reward the presence simply of the attributes listed in the person specification, but the quality and credibility of the evidence provided.

Ultimately, the goal should not be to catch candidates out. It should be to create opportunities for them to demonstrate capability in a meaningful way.

Creating richer evidence

If written applications are becoming less effective at differentiating between candidates, employers need alternative ways of gathering evidence.

That does not necessarily mean introducing lengthy assessment centres or making recruitment processes more complicated. Often relatively simple changes can provide significantly more insight.

Structured interviews, role-specific scenarios, stakeholder discussions, presentations, work samples and practical exercises can all help employers understand how someone thinks, communicates and applies their experience. The aim is not to create an "AI-proof" recruitment process. Such a thing is unlikely to exist.

The aim is to ensure the process continues to reveal what matters.

In reality, most public sector roles require far more than the ability to write a strong supporting statement. We recruit for judgement, leadership, resilience, collaboration, technical expertise and the ability to operate in complex environments. Increasingly, we need recruitment processes that generate evidence of those capabilities.

Employers need guidance too

One aspect of this debate receives far less attention than it deserves.

Many organisations are developing guidance for candidates on the use of AI. Far fewer have developed equivalent guidance for hiring managers.

As AI tools become more accessible, it is easy to imagine applications being uploaded into AI systems to produce summaries, rankings or recommendations. Some organisations may already be exploring these possibilities. Before doing so, there are important questions to answer.

How is AI being used within the recruitment process? What data is being uploaded? Where is that data stored? What role does AI play in decision-making? How are candidates being informed? What safeguards are in place?

If AI is being used anywhere within the recruitment process, organisations should be transparent about it. Recruitment policies, candidate guidance, hiring manager guidance and privacy information should clearly explain where AI is being used, how candidate data is being processed and what role human judgement continues to play. Candidate applications should not be uploaded into an AI tool unless its use has been organisationally approved and the implications for data protection, transparency, storage and decision-making have been properly addressed.

These are not simply technology questions. They are questions of trust, governance and accountability.

If employers expect candidates to use AI responsibly, they should hold themselves to exactly the same standard.

Looking beyond the application

AI is unlikely to disappear from recruitment and, in truth, many organisations would not want it to. Increasingly, we are looking for employees who can use technology effectively, think critically about the outputs it produces and apply professional judgement when using it.

Rather than asking whether candidates should use AI, employers may be better served by asking three different questions:

  • What constitutes acceptable use of AI during our recruitment process?
  • Have we clearly communicated those expectations to candidates and hiring managers?
  • Does our recruitment process still provide the evidence we need to assess capability?

There is a strong argument that organisations should develop and publish guidance on the acceptable use of AI by candidates. If we expect candidates to meet certain standards, it is only fair that they understand what those standards are before they apply. Equally, organisations should consider their own use of AI within recruitment processes, ensuring there is appropriate transparency, governance and accountability wherever these tools are used.

Ultimately, AI is not the problem recruitment needs to solve. The real challenge is ensuring our assessment methods continue to identify the skills, judgement, experience and potential needed to succeed in the role.

Perhaps the question is no longer whether candidates are using AI. Perhaps the question is whether our recruitment processes are still generating the right evidence.

Through our work with HR and resourcing teams across the region, WME continues to explore how recruitment practice can respond to AI while remaining fair, transparent and focused on meaningful evidence.

Find out more about our resourcing support and regional networks

Resourcing Services