The Missing Half of Psychological Safety

Posted on: 11/11/2026

Thought Leadership

Avoiding feedback does not make it kinder. Matthew Masters explores the missing half of psychological safety, helping managers feel safe enough to give honest feedback, not just receive it. He examines how the emotional demands of difficult conversations can affect some neurodivergent managers and explains why asking them to be more confident falls short. Through a four-stage feedback framework and neurodivergent coaching, he explores practical ways to help managers speak clearly, offer support and act even when discomfort remains.

By Matthew Masters, Head of Executive Recruitment & Leadership Advisory at Opus People Solutions 

Psychological safety must extend to the person receiving feedback — and to the manager responsible for saying what needs to be said.

We have become much better at talking about psychological safety in the workplace. We talk about creating environments where employees feel able to speak up, challenge decisions, admit mistakes and receive feedback without fear. That progress matters. But there is another side to psychological safety that receives far less attention.

Do our managers feel psychologically safe enough to give honest feedback in the first place?

It is an important question because giving feedback carries interpersonal risk too. A manager may know that something needs addressing but still hesitate. They may worry about upsetting someone, damaging a relationship, provoking conflict, being accused of unfairness or simply getting the conversation wrong.

So they wait. They soften the message. They surround the difficult point with so much reassurance that the employee leaves without understanding what actually needs to change. Or, perhaps most damagingly, they say nothing until a relatively manageable issue has developed into a significant performance problem.

Feedback avoided does not become kinder. It becomes later, heavier and less fair.

Psychological safety cannot mean avoiding discomfort

Amy Edmondson’s seminal research describes psychological safety as a shared belief that a team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking (Edmondson, 1999). That definition matters because giving feedback is an interpersonal risk.

Psychological safety should not mean creating workplaces in which people are protected from uncomfortable conversations. It should mean creating workplaces where those conversations can happen respectfully, proportionately and without fear.

Psychological safety should make difficult conversations possible, not make difficult conversations disappear.

A psychologically safe organisation can still have high expectations. It can address poor performance, challenge behaviour and hold people accountable. In fact, genuinely psychologically safe organisations should be better at doing those things because people understand that challenge is not the same as personal attack.

But that requires managers to feel equipped and supported. Telling managers to “have courageous conversations” is not enough. We need to give them the structure, language and organisational backing to do it well.

The neurodivergent manager is often missing from this conversation

When we discuss neurodiversity and feedback, the conversation understandably tends to focus on the employee receiving feedback: how communication should be adapted, how feedback can be made clearer and what adjustments might be needed. Those are important questions. But what happens when the manager is neurodivergent?

For some managers with ADHD, emotional regulation, sensitivity to criticism or perceived rejection, rumination and anxiety around interpersonal conflict may influence how a difficult conversation feels. A meta-analysis involving more than 2,500 adults found significantly higher levels of emotional dysregulation among adults with ADHD, particularly emotional lability and negative emotional responses (Beheshti, Chavanon and Christiansen, 2020).

That does not mean every person with ADHD experiences these things. Neurodivergence should never become shorthand for predicting somebody’s behaviour. It does mean, however, that organisations should recognise that the emotional demands of management may interact differently with different neurological profiles.

The term rejection sensitivity dysphoria (RSD) is increasingly used, particularly within ADHD communities, to describe an intense emotional response to perceived criticism or rejection. We need some caution here. RSD is not recognised as a separate clinical diagnosis within DSM-5-TR or ICD-11 (American Psychiatric Association, 2022; World Health Organization, 2022). The evidence surrounding emotional dysregulation in ADHD is more established than the evidence for RSD as a distinct clinical construct.

Useful language for lived experience should not automatically be mistaken for settled clinical science.

Nevertheless, the experience being described can matter enormously in the workplace. A manager may approach a difficult conversation while thinking: What if they believe I am being unfair? What if they react badly? What if I damage the relationship? What if I have misunderstood the situation? For some people, that internal noise can make an already difficult conversation considerably harder.

The answer is not to lower expectations. The answer is to give managers tools that help them act effectively even when the conversation feels uncomfortable.

A four-stage structure for feedback

Structure reduces ambiguity. It gives the manager something reliable to return to when emotion, uncertainty or fear of rejection threatens to take over.


1. OBSERVATION 2. IMPACT3. EXPECTATION4. SUPPORT

Describe what happened

“The report was submitted two days after the agreed deadline.”

Explain why it matters

“The finance team could not complete the board paper on time.”

Clarify what must change

“Future reports must arrive by noon on the agreed date.”

Ask what will enable it

“What support do you need to meet that expectation?”

1. Observation

Start with what you have actually observed — not personality, assumed motivation or judgement. Behaviour creates a more objective starting point and reduces the risk of the conversation becoming personal.

2. Impact

Explain why the behaviour matters. Impact moves the conversation away from blame and towards consequence. It helps the employee understand the effect on colleagues, services, decisions or outcomes.

3. Expectation

Be explicit about what needs to happen differently. Managers can become so concerned about how a message will land that they dilute the very thing the employee needs to understand. If somebody leaves a feedback conversation unsure what needs to change, we have not really given feedback.

4. Support

Ask what support is needed to meet the expectation. This does not remove accountability; it introduces curiosity. The barrier may involve workload, competing priorities, clarity, capability, resources or a reasonable adjustment. A neuroinclusive approach recognises that workplace difficulties can emerge through the interaction between an individual and their environment, rather than automatically locating the “problem” within the person (Doyle, 2020).

Compassion without clarity creates confusion. Accountability without support creates fear. Good management requires both.

But a framework alone may not be enough

For some neurodivergent managers, knowing the framework intellectually and being able to use it when emotions are heightened are two different things. This is where neurodivergent coaching can have an important role.

There is an important distinction to make. Workplace coaching is not therapy, and coaches should not attempt to provide clinical interventions unless they are appropriately qualified to do so. Neurodivergent coaching can, however, help a manager understand their patterns, recognise what happens when discomfort appears and develop practical strategies for responding differently.

One useful lens can come from principles associated with Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), applied appropriately within a coaching rather than therapeutic context. ACT focuses on psychological flexibility: being able to make room for difficult internal experiences while taking action guided by personal values (Hayes, Strosahl and Wilson, 2012). In a workplace coaching context, that idea can help a manager stop treating the disappearance of discomfort as a prerequisite for action.

The manager may still think: They are going to be angry with me. They might reject what I am saying. Perhaps I should leave this until next week. Trying to make those thoughts disappear before acting can become part of the problem. An ACT-informed coaching approach can instead help the manager notice that the thought or feeling is present without automatically allowing it to determine what happens next.

The question is not only “How do I stop feeling uncomfortable?” It is “What would the manager I want to be do in this moment?”

That shifts the focus towards values-led action. Perhaps the manager they want to be is fair, clear, compassionate, honest, consistent and supportive. Perhaps they are prepared to have a difficult conversation because avoiding it would ultimately be less fair to the individual and the wider team.

The discomfort may still be there. But it no longer has to make the decision. The goal is not always to feel comfortable before acting. Sometimes it is to act in accordance with our values while discomfort comes with us.

For a manager who has spent years avoiding situations that trigger fears of criticism or rejection, that shift may take time. This is precisely why telling someone simply to “be more confident” is unlikely to be enough. Coaching can create space to recognise patterns, rehearse conversations, explore triggers, reconnect with leadership values and practise responding differently.

Over time, the manager can move from “How do I protect myself from this conversation?” towards “How can I be the best manager I can be in this conversation?” That is not about changing who somebody is. It is about helping them lead in a way that is consistent with who they want to be.

This is an organisational responsibility

There is a danger that organisations treat difficult feedback purely as an individual confidence problem: send the manager on a course, give them a script and tell them to be braver. But we should look further upstream.

Do managers have somewhere to rehearse difficult conversations? Can neurodivergent managers access coaching that understands both leadership and neurodivergence? Does HR provide proportionate support? Are expectations sufficiently clear? When a manager gives reasonable, evidence-based feedback and receives a difficult reaction, do senior leaders stand behind them?

You cannot ask managers to create psychologically safe teams while leaving managers themselves psychologically exposed.

Organisations need to design for good feedback: clear frameworks, management development, neurodivergent coaching, access to proportionate people advice and cultures where respectful challenge is considered part of a healthy working relationship. Psychological safety and accountability are not opposites. They need each other.

A healthy culture is not one in which nobody ever feels uncomfortable. It is one in which necessary discomfort can be handled fairly, clearly and without shame.


TWO QUESTIONS FOR SENIOR LEADERS

Do our managers genuinely feel equipped and supported to say what needs to be said?

When they hesitate, are we simply asking them to overcome discomfort — or helping them become the manager they want to be?

On 26th November, join Matthew Masters as he explores how councils and public sector organisations can create more inclusive and accessible recruitment processes and workplace experiences for neurodivergent people. 

Find out more and book today